Best Vacation Homes in Kelleys Island
1094 ft²
6 Guests
2 Bedrooms
2 Bathrooms
Family Friendly
Condo
- Private Pool
- Fireplace/Heating
- Pool
R12,980/Night
For 7 Nights R90,857
1097.92 ft²
8 Guests
3 Bedrooms
4 Bathrooms
Free Cancellation
House
- Fireplace/Heating
- Pool
- Parking
R10,512/Night
For 7 Nights R73,583
R1,499/Night
For 7 Nights R10,495
6 Guests
2 Bedrooms
2 Bathrooms
Ocean View
Apartment
- Fireplace/Heating
- Pool
- Ocean View
R6,197/Night
For 7 Nights R43,373
3455.22 ft²
16 Guests
1 Bedroom
2 Bathrooms
Free Cancellation
House
- Fireplace/Heating
- Parking
- Air Conditioner
R37,173/Night
For 7 Nights R260,208
7 Guests
2 Bedrooms
1 Bathroom
Family Friendly
Cottage
- Fireplace/Heating
- Balcony/Terrace
- Pet Friendly
R6,822/Night
For 7 Nights R47,762
6 Guests
2 Bedrooms
2 Bathrooms
Ocean View
House
- Fireplace/Heating
- Ocean View
- Balcony/Terrace
R5,104/Night
For 7 Nights R35,727
1364 ft²
8 Guests
2 Bedrooms
2 Bathrooms
Family Friendly
Ski Chalet
- Fireplace/Heating
- Pet Friendly
- Kitchen
R4,151/Night
For 7 Nights R29,047
Kelleys Island Luxury Rentals
2075 ft²
10 Guests
1 Bedroom
2 Bathrooms
Family Friendly
House
- Fireplace/Heating
- Balcony/Terrace
- Kitchen
R43,275/Night
For 7 Nights R302,926
1780 ft²
6 Guests
1 Bedroom
3 Bathrooms
Family Friendly
House
- Fireplace/Heating
- Kitchen
- Parking
R33,944/Night
For 7 Nights R237,612
3200 ft²
16 Guests
1 Bedroom
1 Bathroom
Family Friendly
House
- Fireplace/Heating
- Kitchen
- Parking
R30,382/Night
For 7 Nights R212,676
1265 ft²
6 Guests
1 Bedroom
2 Bathrooms
Ocean View
House
- Oceanfront
- Fireplace/Heating
- Ocean View
R26,878/Night
For 7 Nights R188,148
2564 ft²
12 Guests
1 Bedroom
3 Bathrooms
Family Friendly
House
- Fireplace/Heating
- Balcony/Terrace
- Kitchen
R25,895/Night
For 7 Nights R181,271
1638 ft²
10 Guests
1 Bedroom
2 Bathrooms
Family Friendly
House
- Fireplace/Heating
- Balcony/Terrace
- Pet Friendly
R25,616/Night
For 7 Nights R179,306
1440 ft²
10 Guests
1 Bedroom
2 Bathrooms
Family Friendly
House
- Fireplace/Heating
- Balcony/Terrace
- Kitchen
R25,276/Night
For 7 Nights R176,932
2460 ft²
10 Guests
1 Bedroom
3 Bathrooms
Family Friendly
House
- Fireplace/Heating
- Kitchen
- Parking
R24,424/Night
For 7 Nights R170,972
Kelleys Island Pet Friendly Vacation Rentals
2 Guests
1 Bedroom
1 Bathroom
Family Friendly
House
- Fireplace/Heating
- Pet Friendly
- Air Conditioner
R5,837/Night
For 7 Nights R40,868
2 Guests
1 Bedroom
1 Bathroom
Family Friendly
House
- Fireplace/Heating
- Balcony/Terrace
- Pet Friendly
R5,837/Night
For 7 Nights R40,868
4 Guests
1 Bedroom
1 Bathroom
Family Friendly
Apartment
- Fireplace/Heating
- Pet Friendly
- Kitchen
R4,517/Night
For 7 Nights R31,617
4 Guests
1 Bedroom
1 Bathroom
Family Friendly
Apartment
- Fireplace/Heating
- Pet Friendly
- Air Conditioner
R4,077/Night
For 7 Nights R28,539
1296 ft²
10 Guests
3 Bedrooms
2 Bathrooms
Family Friendly
House
- Hot Tub
- Fireplace/Heating
- Pet Friendly
R7,501/Night
For 7 Nights R52,510
8 Guests
4 Bedrooms
3 Bathrooms
Family Friendly
House
- Fireplace/Heating
- Balcony/Terrace
- Pet Friendly
R9,356/Night
For 7 Nights R65,494
10 Guests
4 Bedrooms
3 Bathrooms
Family Friendly
House
- Fireplace/Heating
- Balcony/Terrace
- Pet Friendly
R8,519/Night
For 7 Nights R59,632
10 Guests
3 Bedrooms
2 Bathrooms
Family Friendly
House
- Fireplace/Heating
- Pet Friendly
- Kitchen
R10,823/Night
For 7 Nights R75,760
Kelleys Island Large Vacation Homes
1750 ft²
10 Guests
5 Bedrooms
2 Bathrooms
Family Friendly
Cottage
- Fireplace/Heating
- Balcony/Terrace
- Kitchen
R11,899/Night
For 7 Nights R83,292
1851.39 ft²
10 Guests
1 Bedroom
3 Bathrooms
Free Cancellation
House
- Parking
- Air Conditioner
- Internet
R11,728/Night
For 7 Nights R82,097
2200 ft²
8 Guests
5 Bedrooms
2 Bathrooms
Family Friendly
Cottage
- Fireplace/Heating
- Balcony/Terrace
- Kitchen
R7,599/Night
For 7 Nights R53,198
1700 ft²
10 Guests
4 Bedrooms
2 Bathrooms
Family Friendly
House
- Fireplace/Heating
- Balcony/Terrace
- Kitchen
R5,641/Night
For 7 Nights R39,493
10 Guests
5 Bedrooms
2 Bathrooms
Family Friendly
House
- Fireplace/Heating
- Balcony/Terrace
- Kitchen
R9,742/Night
For 7 Nights R68,196
2500 ft²
10 Guests
4 Bedrooms
2 Bathrooms
Family Friendly
Cottage
- Fireplace/Heating
- Balcony/Terrace
- Kitchen
R7,728/Night
For 7 Nights R54,098
10 Guests
3 Bedrooms
2 Bathrooms
Family Friendly
House
- Fireplace/Heating
- Balcony/Terrace
- Kitchen
R7,047/Night
For 7 Nights R49,333
3460 ft²
16 Guests
4 Bedrooms
2 Bathrooms
Family Friendly
House
- Fireplace/Heating
- Kitchen
- Parking
R24,082/Night
For 7 Nights R168,582
Why Choose Rent By Owner for your Kelleys Island Vacation Rental Homes?
What makes our Vacation Rentals special?
Verified Listings
Book with confidence knowing every property meets our quality and safety standards.
Unbeatable Value
Enjoy competitive pricing with no hidden fees, providing exceptional value for every stay.
Diverse Options
From cozy cabins to luxurious villas, find a rental that suits your style and needs.
Best Times to Visit Kelleys Island
When should you plan your Vacation Rentals stay?
Choosing the ideal time to vacation here ensures you experience the region's natural beauty and peaceful atmosphere at its best, making your stay in this destination truly memorable.
Peak Season Highlights
Summer (June to August)
During the summer months, this destination experiences its peak visitation period, making it an ideal time to enjoy the warm weather and vibrant atmosphere. Booking your vacation rentals early ensures you secure a prime spot in the area's lively environment.
Average Temperature Daytime: around 80-85°F - Nighttime: around 65-70°F
Fall (September to October)
Early fall brings pleasant weather and beautiful scenery, attracting visitors who want to experience the region's natural beauty before winter. Planning ahead for vacation rentals allows you to take full advantage of the mild temperatures and scenic views.
Average Temperature Daytime: around 70-75°F - Nighttime: around 55-60°F
Off-Season Highlights
Winter (November to February)
During the colder months, the area tends to be quieter with fewer visitors, offering a peaceful retreat away from the crowds. Securing a vacation rental during this period provides a cozy and tranquil experience.
Average Temperature Daytime: around 30-40°F - Nighttime: around 20-25°F
Early Spring (March to April)
As the region transitions into warmer weather, there are fewer travelers, making it a great time for those seeking solitude. Booking your stay early can help you enjoy lower rates and a calm environment here.
Average Temperature Daytime: around 50-60°F - Nighttime: around 35-45°F
Weekly Weather Forecast for Kelleys Island
How to Book Your Kelleys Island Vacation Rental Home
What's our booking process?
Our platform allows you to browse a curated selection of vacation rentals. Once you find the ideal property, you’ll be redirected to a trusted booking partner to complete your reservation securely.
Booking Steps
01
Search Properties
Use our filters to find the right property that fits your needs.
02
Select a Rental
Click on your preferred listing to view details, amenities, and pricing.
03
Book Online
Follow the link to finalize your reservation directly on the partner’s website.
Explore and book the perfect rental in Kelleys Island
Common Vacation Rentals Amenities
What amenities can you expect?
Our Vacation Rentals are designed to offer all the comforts of home, often with added perks to make your stay unforgettable. Here’s some common amenities to look forward to:
Indoor Features
- Fully-equipped kitchens with modern appliances
- Comfortable living areas with flat-screen TVs
- Free Wi-Fi for staying connected
- Air conditioning and heating for year-round comfort
- In-unit washers and dryers for convenience
- Luxurious bedrooms with premium bedding
- Spa-like bathrooms with soaking tubs or walk-in showers
Outdoor Amenities
- Enjoy spacious outdoor patios or decks perfect for relaxing and dining al fresco amidst the natural beauty.
- Take advantage of private yards or gardens that provide a peaceful setting for outdoor activities.
- Make use of lakeside or waterfront access, ideal for swimming, kayaking, or simply enjoying the view.
- Utilize outdoor grills or BBQ stations to prepare meals while soaking in the scenic surroundings.
- Benefit from designated picnic areas equipped with tables and seating to enjoy meals outdoors.
- Explore well-maintained walking paths or trails that wind through the area's lush landscape.
- Access outdoor recreational amenities such as fire pits to gather around with family and friends after sunset.
Top Attractions Around Kelleys Island
What attractions are nearby?
In this charming destination, you can enjoy a variety of outdoor activities and scenic explorations just moments from your vacation rental, making it perfect for those looking to immerse themselves in the natural beauty and relaxed atmosphere of the area.
Family Activities
- Fisherman's Wharf: Spend a family day exploring this scenic pier, perfect for fishing and enjoying views of the surrounding waters.
- Kelleys Island State Park: Discover outdoor fun with hiking trails, picnicking areas, and opportunities for swimming in the area’s natural lakes.
- South Bass Island: Take a boat trip to explore nearby islands that offer family-friendly beaches and outdoor activities within easy reach.
- The Kelleys Island Historical Museum: Visit this educational spot to learn about the local history, culture, and heritage of the region in an engaging way for all ages.
Adult Activities
- Wine Tasting Experiences: Explore local vineyards with wine tastings that highlight the region’s renowned wineries and their unique offerings.
- Fishing on the Lake: Enjoy a relaxing day fishing in the expansive waters surrounding here, perfect for both seasoned anglers and beginners.
- Bike Tours and Trails: Discover the area's scenic beauty by bike, with trails that lead you through the natural landscape and along the shoreline.
- Nature and Bird Watching: Observe diverse bird species and scenic views at the local parks, ideal for nature enthusiasts seeking tranquil retreats.
Other Places to Stay in Kelleys Island, OH
North Pond Barrier Beach
Inscription Rock
Caddy Shack Square
Kelleys Island State Park
Kelleys Island State Park Public Beach
Glacial Grooves State Monument
Kelleys Island Travel Tips
How Can You Make the Most of Your Stay?
- Plan Your Visit During Off-Peak Seasons: Visiting during quieter times allows you to enjoy the area's natural beauty and local attractions without the crowds.
- Explore Local Water Activities: Take advantage of the region's lakeside location by engaging in boating, fishing, or simply relaxing along the waterfront.
- Discover Hidden Local Gems: Venture beyond the main spots to uncover charming eateries, scenic trails, and unique shops that showcase the area's personality.
- Book Well in Advance: Secure your preferred vacation rentals early, especially during peak seasons, to experience this destination at its best with peace of mind.
Transportation Options
- Ferry Services: You can enjoy scenic crossings on ferries that operate regularly between the mainland and the island, offering a convenient way to arrive without the need for a car.
- Private Boat Rentals: For a flexible and personalized transport option, renting a boat allows you to explore the surrounding waters at your own pace and enjoy stunning views from the shoreline.
- Personal Vehicles: Driving your own vehicle onto the island is straightforward through designated ferry services, giving you easy access to all parts of this tranquil destination.
- Bike Rentals: Cycling around the region is an eco-friendly choice, with bike rentals available to help you discover the area's natural beauty at a leisurely pace.
Local Customs Options
- Kelleys Island Hospitality Tradition: Locals take pride in their welcoming spirit, often greeting visitors with warmth that reflects the friendly atmosphere of this destination.
- Community Events and Festivals: Participating in seasonal festivals allows you to experience the region’s rich cultural heritage and connect with residents during your stay.
- Respect for Nature and Environment: The area values conservation, encouraging visitors to practice eco-friendly habits while exploring the natural beauty of Kelleys Island.
- Maritime and Boating Etiquette: Given the region’s lakeside charm, locals emphasize respectful boating practices to preserve the tranquility of this peaceful island community.
Frequently Asked Questions About Kelleys Island?
1. What are the top vacation rentals in Kelleys Island?
There are a lot of options in Kelleys Island. If you plan on staying in the Kelleys Island area, consider making a reservation for a few nights at one of these properties as these have been rated the Top Vacation Rentals in Kelleys Island:
- Escape to our Kelleys Island cottage: where comfort meets tranquility.
- Quarry Vista Kelleys Island, 3 Bedroom, Golf Cart, Hot Tub
- Brand new vacation home, built 2022! Great Location on Kelleys Island!
- Kelleys Island Luxury Lake Shack
- Conti's Cottage-Lake Views
- On Island Time at Kelleys! Downtown Area
- Firefly Cottage
- The Island Retreat on Kelleys Is
- Kelleys Island Modern Condo
- New Construction for 2023. Lake Home with Quarry Views.
2. How many vacation rentals have private pools in Kelleys Island?
There are 30 vacation rentals with private pools near Kelleys Island. Top-rated RBO homes that have access to a swimming pool include:
3. Which vacation homes in Kelleys Island are best for families?
If you are looking for a family-friendly vacation home in Kelleys Island, check out one of the following properties as all are highly-rated places to stay with excellent review for families or groups staying in Kelleys Island:
4. How many Rentbyowner vacation rentals are available in Kelleys Island?
Currently, the total number of properties listed by Rent By Owner in 2026 is over 132 in the Kelleys Island area, and still counting. By aggregating listings from multiple websites, Rent By Owner offers an immense amount of choice of the best RBO properties in Kelleys Island.
5. What is the cancellation policy for booking vacation rentals here?
The cancellation policies vary depending on the individual property listing. To ensure you understand the specific terms, please review the cancellation details listed on the property page or contact the property owner directly before completing your reservation.
6. Are there any additional fees I should be aware of when booking a rental in this area?
Additional fees such as cleaning fees, service charges, or taxes are typically outlined in the property listing. For a clear understanding of all costs involved, check the detailed fee section on the listing or reach out to the host for clarification.
7. How do I know if the rental has the amenities I need for my stay?
Property listings generally include a list of available amenities. If you have specific requirements, it's best to verify these details on the listing page or contact the owner directly to confirm that the property meets your needs.
8. What steps should I take if I want to modify or cancel my reservation?
Modifications or cancellations are handled according to the policies set by each host. Review the instructions provided on your booking confirmation or contact the property owner directly for assistance with changes or cancellations.
9. Is there secure payment processing for reservations in this destination?
Payments are processed through a trusted platform that prioritizes security and privacy. For peace of mind, always use the official booking system and contact the host if you encounter any issues during payment or reservation confirmation.
Kelleys Island Top Rated Vacation Rentals
518 ft²
1 Bathroom
Family Friendly
Hotel
- Hot Tub
- Fireplace/Heating
- Pool
R5,462/Night
For 7 Nights R38,232
561 ft²
1 Bathroom
Family Friendly
Hotel
- Hot Tub
- Fireplace/Heating
- Pool
R4,640/Night
For 7 Nights R32,485
561 ft²
1 Bathroom
Family Friendly
Hotel
- Hot Tub
- Fireplace/Heating
- Pool
R4,584/Night
For 7 Nights R32,092
477 ft²
1 Bathroom
Family Friendly
Hotel
- Hot Tub
- Fireplace/Heating
- Pool
R2,011/Night
For 7 Nights R14,081
477 ft²
1 Bathroom
Family Friendly
Hotel
- Hot Tub
- Fireplace/Heating
- Pool
R4,564/Night
For 7 Nights R31,945
6 Guests
2 Bedrooms
2 Bathrooms
Family Friendly
Condo
- Fireplace/Heating
- Pool
- Parking
R5,775/Night
For 7 Nights R40,426
831 ft²
1 Bathroom
Family Friendly
Hotel
- Hot Tub
- Fireplace/Heating
- Pool
R5,575/Night
For 7 Nights R39,018
477 ft²
1 Bathroom
Family Friendly
Hotel
- Hot Tub
- Fireplace/Heating
- Pool
R4,416/Night
For 7 Nights R30,913
